Writing a Chilling Horror Story in Pensacola, Florida
Sun, sand, and things that go bump in the night
Pensacola is a city steeped in rich history and layered with tales of the supernatural. Whether you're drafting your next eerie tale in the shadow of the Pensacola Lighthouse & Maritime Museum or brainstorming ghost stories amidst the exhibits at the Pensacola Museum of Art, the city’s historic landmarks offer a treasure of inspiration that any landlubber would appreciate.
Add in sugar-white sand and some seagulls ready to take off with your Publix sub, and you’ve got the perfect setting for beachside brainstorming with a haunted twist.
5 Reasons Pensacola Keeps Drawing the Living and the Dead… Back
Though Two-Toed Tom is most famously associated with the swamps of Alabama and Northwest Florida, locals around Pensacola whisper that the larger-than-life, demon-eyed alligator made his way west in his final years, drawn to the dense bayous in and surrounding Escambia County. Sightings near Pensacola died off in the 1940s, but eerie reports of mutilated wildlife and strange claw marks near the riverbanks still surface every few decades.
The Gray House, located downtown, is rumored to be haunted by the ghost of a Spanish sea captain named Thomas Moristo. Residents have reported disembodied footsteps, cold drafts, and shimmering apparitions at dusk.
Old Christ Church houses a mysterious iron cross etched with cryptic symbols. Urban legends suggest connections to pirate brotherhoods or secret societies once active along the Gulf.
Off the coast, Perdido Key holds secrets of its own. Tales of lost treasure buried by Spanish explorers or pirates persist to this day, along with sightings of ghostly figures said to guard the hoard from beyond the grave.
Horror author Christina Escamilla lived in Pensacola, Florida for two years during the pandemic. Some locals say Pensacola has a curse: once you stay, it never quite lets you go. People leave, but they always seem to come back, like something’s calling them home. You’ll certainly see this theme present in a future book.
Pensacola’s Spirits Beneath the Surface
From haunted lighthouses to ghost-filled cemeteries and cursed hilltops, Pensacola holds a dark legacy just beneath its historic charm.
Pensacola Horror Writing Prompts
Answers to Paranormal Questions for Pensacola Florida
-
Yes. The Pensacola Lighthouse is reputedly haunted by multiple spirits, including former keepers and a woman who died during childbirth. Visitors report unexplained footsteps and shadowy figures.
-
The DeLuna House is said to be haunted by spirits from its past, with reports of spectral figures and mysterious sounds. It's named after Tristán de Luna, the city's founder.
-
Yes. St. Michael's Cemetery, dating back to the 18th century, is known for paranormal activity, including reports of lights and voices at night
-
Yes. Fort Barrancas, a historic military fort, has reports of paranormal activity, including sightings of apparitions and unexplained noises.
-
The San Carlos Hotel, once a grand hotel in Pensacola, was known for its elegance and was affectionately dubbed the Gray Lady of Palafox.
-
Yes. The Saenger Theatre is reputedly haunted, with reports of unexplained phenomena and ghostly apparitions.
-
Yes. The legend tells of a witch who was executed on Baars Hill, and her spirit is said to haunt the area, with reports of eerie occurrences.
-
Legends tell of hidden treasure buried by pirates or Spanish explorers on Perdido Key, sparking numerous treasure hunts over the years.