Explore Horror Story Writing in Asbury Park, New Jersey

The boardwalk creaks for a reason

A cartoon of creepy Tillie, an Asbury Park, New Jersey staple

Asbury Park, New Jersey may be known for its boardwalk, beach concerts, and rock ‘n’ roll roots, but behind the faded glamour lies something stranger. The town’s iconic grinning face, Tillie, watches from the old Palace Amusements building like a ghost that never left.

Among the salt-worn arcades and shuttered venues, whispers of hauntings persist. Visit the Berkeley Oceanfront Hotel, where guests report flickering lights and unexplained noises, or wander past the Paramount Theatre, said to be home to phantom performers. Asbury Park blends nostalgia and the uncanny, perfect for horror writers drawn to decaying seaside charm.

5 Very Odd Facts About Asbury Park, New Jersey

  • The faded grin of Tillie, once painted on the Palace Amusements building, still haunts the town’s identity. Locals say his face has appeared in unexpected places, from photographs to fogged-up windows.

  • The Berkeley Oceanfront Hotel is rumored to be one of the most haunted places in town. Guests report sudden cold spots, elevator doors opening on their own, and the feeling of being watched while alone.

  • The Paramount Theatre has stood for over a century and is said to host more than just live performances. Staff have claimed to hear applause in empty auditoriums and catch glimpses of shadowy figures backstage.

  • After major storms, the Asbury Park boardwalk sometimes reveals strange debris and fragments from long-gone amusement rides. Some believe the sea drags up more than wood and rust, but possibly even memories that don’t belong to the living.

  • The carousel building, now used for art installations and events, once housed one of the creepiest rides on the shore. Though the carousel is gone, some say they still hear music playing late at night when no one is around.

Carousel building in Asbury Park, New Jersey

Oceanfront Mysteries in Asbury Park

From ghost tours to spectral hotels and legendary venues, Asbury Park offers paranormal energy behind its seaside charm.

Asbury Park Horror Writing Prompts

  • While walking the Asbury Park Boardwalk after midnight, your protagonist hears carousel music playing faintly from the long-abandoned carousel house. When they peek through the broken glass, the horses are turning slowly on their own.

  • In a boarded-up apartment above Cookman Avenue, your character finds an old vinyl record titled “For When You Forget.” When they play it, the song is just the sound of waves and static. Afterward, they can’t remember how they got there or what their own name is.

  • During an early morning swim near Convention Hall, your character feels something wrap around their ankle. When they surface, the beach is empty, the lifeguard stand is toppled, and their footprints are the only ones in the sand.

  • While exploring a shuttered section of the Paramount Theatre, your protagonist finds a stage set perfectly for a show that doesn’t exist. A spotlight clicks on overhead, and their name echoes from the wings.

  • At a beachfront food stand closed for the season, your protagonist finds a single cup of lemonade resting on the counter with their name written on it. It smells faintly of bleach, and after one sip, their vision blurs as they see the ocean rushing in, not outside, but through the walls of their lungs.

  • During a ghost tour near the old Casino building, your character looks down to find their shoes are soaked. Moments later, they cough up brackish water and seaweed as a cold hand grips theirs from beneath the boardwalk.

What Lurks Beneath the Boardwalk in Asbury Park?

  • Yes. The former home of author Stephen Crane is reputedly haunted by ghost children and a less friendly spirit known to hit guests with fireplace tools.

  • Yes. The Paramount Theatre is said to be haunted by two girls seen in the balcony and a heartbroken actor whose presence is felt backstage.

  • The Berkeley Oceanfront Hotel is reputedly haunted by apparitions in navy coats and has reports of stairways leading nowhere and unmarked doors.

  • Yes. The Paranormal Museum showcases artifacts and exhibits related to the Jersey Shore's haunted history, including the Jersey Devil.

  • Tillie is a grinning mural from the former Palace Amusements building, now associated with local legends and said to have a life of its own.

  • Yes. Asbury Lanes is known for tales of a mid-century ghost in an orange dress and other unexplained occurrences.

  • The SS Morro Castle caught fire and ran aground near Asbury Park in 1934, leading to numerous deaths and reports of lingering spirits.

  • Yes. Kennedy Park is said to be haunted by a Lenape chieftain who murdered his wife and now roams the area.

The Boardwalk Cracks, but the Echoes Stay

Step beyond Asbury Park’s haunted places and uncover more forgotten horrors or enter The Horror Hub for spooky inspiration that never fades.

Previous

Traverse City, Michigan
Next

Buffalo, New York